PAGE 13 San Antonio Business Journal April 10, 1989 SECTION: Vol 3; No 12; Sec 1; pg 1 LENGTH: 1962 words HEADLINE: Report Accuses Dominguez of Fraud BYLINE: Donna Kenny DATELINE: CA; US BODY: A California federal bankruptcy court issued a preliminary injunction on March 29 prohibiting developer H. Frank Dominguez and his family from shuffling assets between businesses after a bankruptcy examiner filed a report alleging that Dominguez's business failure resulted from acts of "dishonesty and gross mismanagement." Compiled by an examiner appointed by a U.S. Bankruptcy Court judge in California, the 159-page report concludes that Dominguez was responsible for repeated instances of fraud and self-dealing, and recommends that a variety of property and financial transactions Dominguez orchestrated through a group of companies in his control should be voided due to fraud. The report also alleges that Dominguez supported a lavish lifestyle at the expense of his creditors-using a chauffeur-driven limousine to drive to and from bankruptcy hearings and funneling money from his companies for $ 700,000 in renovations to his mountaintop luxury home. Some of the examiner's other allegations include claims that: * Dominguez committed fraudulent transfers of his assets to his family relations to the point that his business affairs were "hopelessly entangled." * Dominguez failed to maintain adequate financial records and failed to file tax returns for 1986 and 1987. * Dominguez claimed his net worth was $ 52 million at a time when he was unable to meet his debts and borrowed more than $ 40 million that he could not pay back. * Dominguez was guilty of "gross mismanagement." "We received the report just a couple of days ago, and have not had a chance to respond," Dominguez said, adding, though, that he found the various allegations "very inaccurate." "My observation was that there are a lot of assumptions made in a very negative sense," said Dominguez. Dominguez said that he would be preparing a point-by-point response to the report, but could not now address questions on PAGE 14 San Antonio Business Journal 1989 UMI/Data Courier specific allegations. As a result of the allegations, the bankruptcy examiner is recommending that all the Vanir companies-a group of eight companies that Dominguez controls-be consolidated, and creditors seek to void or "set aside" Dominguez's past transfers of real estate and money. The move to void Dominguez's financial transfers is based on allegations that Dominguez violated U.S. Bankruptcy laws and a California law that states that transfers can be nullified if they were done with the intent to hinder, delay or defraud creditors. The bankruptcy examiner, Leonard Gumport, stresses that the results of his investigation are not a court decision or a finding from a jury, but his opinion based on interviews and accounting documents. As a result of Gumport's report, Judge William Lasarow of the U.S. Bankruptcy Court of the Central District of California ordered a bankruptcy trustee be appointed to take custody of Dominguez's business affairs. In addition, Judge Lasarow ordered a preliminary injunction on March 29 prohibiting Dominguez and his family from shuffling assets between businesses and individuals. Dominguez, the developer of Fiesta Plaza, Ramada Inn, the Control Data Building and other beleaguered projects on the city-owned land in Vista Verde, filed for Chapter 11 bankruptcy protection in California on Jan. 22, 1988, amid numerous lawsuits by lenders threatening to foreclose. In an effort to stave off those foreclosures, the city of San Antonio filed a petition to force Immer Vista Verde, one of Dominguez's development companies into involuntary Chapter 11 reorganization here in San Antonio. A proposed agreement between the city and Dominguez to free up the Vista Verde land for new development and dissolve the involuntary bankruptcy was approved by the California bankruptcy court last week. However, in the midst of the compromise agreement, Dominguez was slapped with the reams of documents from Leonard Gumport, bankruptcy examiner for Dominguez's affairs. The report was based on examination by the law firm Hufstedler, Miller, Kaus & Beardsley in Los Angeles and records from the accounting firm Neilson, Elggren, Durkin & Co. In the past, Dominguez has blamed his failed projects on the Texas economy. The Gumport report, though, places virtually the entire blame on Dominguez. "Dominguez must bear the blame for all or nearly all of his Texas problems," Gumport said in the report. The bankruptcy report outlines Dominguez's business affairs in California and Texas from 1985 to the present. As of December 1985, Dominguez is the record owner of 100 percent of the stock of Vanir Group, the top-tier holding company for at least eight corporate subsidiaries. The report refers to the Vanir Group and its wholly owned subsidiary Vanir Development Co. as "corporate shells that Dominguez uses to hold his fraudulently transferred assets and funds." PAGE 15 San Antonio Business Journal 1989 UMI/Data Courier Dominguez comingled the business assets and debts between several of his Vanir companies including Vanir Group, Vanir Development and a "fictitious" business known as Vanir Research Co., the report alleges. Over the past four years, Dominguez has borrowed more than $ 40 million from numerous financial institutions and individuals and has paid back almost none of it, the report alleges. During this time, Dominguez claimed he had a net worth of $ 52 million, despite many signs that he was struggling financially, the report alleges. For example, the report contends, tax returns prepared by Dominguez's accounting firm reflect a negative cash flow overall for each year from 1984 through 1986. In addition, Dominguez had difficulty making payments on a court judgment that the Kraus-Anderson Mortgage Co. received against Dominguez for more than $ 800,000 in 1985. In response to his growing debts, "Dominguez concealed his financial difficulties with a grossly misleading financial statement which exaggerated his net worth," the report alleges. In addition, Dominguez "made fraudulent or otherwise voidable transfers of his assets to his family members, to corporations controlled by him and to insiders," the report contends. Some of those transfers allegedly include: * In an effort to remove $ 4.2 million from his balance sheets and beyond the reach of his creditors, Dominguez transferred 50 percent of the stock of Vanir Group of Companies Inc. to his wife and children; * between 1986 and 1987 Dominguez transferred various corporations including the Law Center of San Bernardino, Center City Food Services and a $ 650,000 California mountaintop home, known as the Big Bear Property, out of his name and into the Vanir Group; * in 1986, Dominguez received more than $ 1 million from the sale of his Colton Cablevision Co. and "fraudulently" transferred these funds to Vanir Group, and Vanir Group used the funds "as part of a fraudulent scheme" to acquire title to Vanir Tower. The report also alleges that during a time when he was experiencing "severe financial problems," Dominguez committed "gross mismanagement." Claims of mismanagement were backed up by allegations that Dominguez takes funds from the rents of income-producing properties that belong to his bankruptcy estate and funnels them through Vanir Development "so that he can pay the upkeep on his house, pay credit card bills, support his children and parents, vacation in his mountaintop resort, and go to and from bankruptcy court in a chauffeur-driven limousine," the report alleges. Gumport's report also alleges that the creditors' committee overseeing Dominguez's bankruptcy failed to function properly, and that one corporate entity "engaged in a secret act of self-dealing." PAGE 16 San Antonio Business Journal 1989 UMI/Data Courier Gumport alleges that after the first creditors meeting, "the committee did nothing." In addition, Gumport alleges that Marathon National Bank, a financial institution in West Los Angeles, and the chairman of the creditors' committee, engaged in an unauthorized settlement with Dominguez by accepting a trust deed to hold Big Bear property until Dominguez paid his debt to the company. In return, Marathon agreed to refrain from objecting to Dominguez's attempt to discharge himself from the bankruptcy, the report alleges. Gumport alleges that Marathon knew that Dominguez fraudulently transferred the Big Bear property to Vanir, because the lender had previously filed legal papers objecting to Dominguez's discharge. Marathon, however, vehemently denies those allegations, saying there is much more to the story than what's available in Gumport's report. Marathon claims that its officers never reviewed its legal pleadings before they were filed and were unaware that Dominguez had "fraudulently" transferred the property. Gumport was acting as an "advocate" as opposed to an "independent fact finder which he is required to be under the Bankruptcy Code," Marathon alleges in its legal papers opposing the appointment of a trustee. In addition, Marathon asserts that its settlement with Vanir was no secret, and that the creditors' committee was aware of it. Marathon also alleges that its settlement actually benefited other creditors because it decreased Marathon's claim by more than $ 220,000. Finally, Marathon alleges that its settlement with Dominguez was in line with normal bankruptcy procedures. It contends that if a trustee is appointed, he would only liquidate the estate and creditors would get "little, if nothing." Another large portion of the report focuses on the pending litigation and claims surrounding the Vista Verde South project that Dominguez developed with loans from local and out-of-state thrifts and federal grants from the U.S. Department of Housing and Urban Development. Dominguez formed a joint venture with two local developers David Saks and Doyle Spruill, and named their partnership Omni/Vanir Vista Verde South Joint Venture. In 1984, Omni/Vanir hired George Smith Financial Services, a loan broker in Southern California, to help the partnership find funding to build the Ramada Hotel. According to the report, George Smith Financial approached Southern California Federal Savings and Loan (SoCal) to make a construction loan to the partnership in return for Omni/Vanir's purchase of a piece of SoCal's foreclosed property at the thrift's book value. After SoCal loaned Omni/Vanir $ 11.6 million and the partnership agreed to buy the Hazelwood Apartments in California, the partnership got into financial trouble and defaulted on the loan. At a meeting in SoCal's offices in December 1985, SoCal's officers told the partnership that the loan would not be PAGE 17 San Antonio Business Journal 1989 UMI/Data Courier extended until management problems were solved. Dominguez alleges that SoCal instructed him to buy out the interest of Saks and Spruill. SoCal denies this. At any rate, Dominguez bought out the 50 percent interest of Saks and Spruill. Meanwhile, Sikes Construction, the general contractor for Ramada, had not been paid for more than a month, the report alleges. During this time, Dominguez needed about $ 650,000 to fund the Saks/Spruill buy-out and used $ 597,407 from SoCal, designated to pay Sikes construction, for the buy-out, the report alleges. In late August 1986, Sikes construction walked off the job. The Ramada Hotel remains unfinished. This episode resulted in SoCal moving to foreclose on the hotel in April 1987. Dominguez and Omni/Vanir filed suit against the thrift alleging it violated usury laws when it required the partnership to purchase the Hazelwood Apartments. That litigation is still pending. In the recent settlement between the city and Dominguez, Dominguez will release his rights to the land and complete Ramada Inn, provided he obtain financing. Gumport's report lists numerous debts Dominguez owes including several to a friend, Lily Wong, who loaned him money to purchase a Church's Fried Chicken restaurant and invest in a movie. SUBJECT: Developers; Federal court decisions; Bankruptcy; Fraud; Debt management; Holding companies; Litigation; Pacific; Southwest NAME: H. Frank Dominiguez GEOGRAPHIC: Southwest Region; San Antonio; TX; US COMPANY: Immer Vista Verde Inc; SIC: 6552 Vanir Group of Cos Inc; SIC: 6719 Marathon National Bank; DUNS: 10-652-1016; SIC: 6021 LOAD-DATE-MDC: July 6, 1990 PAGE 18 LEVEL 1 - 50 OF 81 STORIES