PAGE 19 San Antonio Business Journal August 17, 1990 SECTION: Vol 4; No 31; Sec 1; pg 4 LENGTH: 1035 words HEADLINE: Sale of Long-Distance Firm in 1983 Spawns Legal Tangle in Local Courts BYLINE: Ashley Blaker DATELINE: San Antonio; TX; US BODY: The 1983 purchase of Long Distance Services Inc. of San Antonio by Metromedia Long Distance Inc. of New Jersey has culminated in three recent lawsuits seeking more than $ 5 million now pending in local courts. The charges leveled in the recent suits are made by both the LDS successor companies and former LDS officers and investors. Allegations range from failure to provide indemnity for officers, to supposed fraudulent accounting methods following the sale agreement. The first of the recent suits was filed by LDS former President Gary Scott of San Antonio. In 1984, Scott was a defendant in a stock trade suit filed by two investors in LDS. In April, Scott was ordered to pay the investors $ 4,347,440 for failing to disclose the circumstances of the upcoming Metromedia buy-out to them before repurchasing their LDS stock in 1981, Scott's new suit states. Scott is now seeking to recover the $ 4.3 million damages awarded in April from LDS's successor, Metromedia, alleging that the company promised to indemnify its officers and directors for any negligence suits brought against them. Scott joined forces with the two former investors, Robert Hughes and Johnnie Rogers of Austin, to pursue the suit. To partly satisfy the judgment against him, Scott has assigned 60 percent of his claim against LDS to the former investors. The three have now joined as plaintiffs in a suit seeking to recover the $ 4.3 million award from the recent settlement, plus punitive damages and interest from the long-distance company, according to the suit. Metromedia Long Distance Inc. of Texas was merged into Communications Services Inc. last month. Metromedia Co. is the New Jersey parent company. It succeeded Metromedia Inc. in 1986. Communications Services and Metromedia Co. have filed two separate suits, one denying Scott's indemnity claims, and another suing Scott and 18 other former investors in LDS for breach of contract in the 1983 sale. In its suit denying indemnity, Communications Services alleges that the long-distance service has no liability for the judgment awarded on the 1984 suit because it was dismissed from the original lawsuit in 1985 after settling with Hughes and Rogers, the suit states. PAGE 20 San Antonio Business Journal 1990 UMI/Data Courier The local attorney for Scott, Hughes and Rogers said that the terms of the 1985 settlement didn't affect his clients' claims. "It was a settlement of claims that Hughes and Rogers had against LDS. But it wasn't a settlement of claims that Gary Scott had for indemnity," said Steven Walraven of Shaddox, Compere, Gorham & Good. In its breach of contract suit, Metromedia asks for the return of about $ 1.3 million in payments made to the former stockholders in LDS in 1983 and 1984 as part of a post-sale profit payment clause in the buy-out agreement. Metromedia acquired all of the outstanding stock in LDS in 1983 for $ 30 million, plus 20 percent of the net income from LDS for the next five years. In the first two years after the purchase, former LDS stockholders were paid $ 1,265,966 of the profits made in the two years, according to the suit. But since 1985, LDS has lost money. Over the five-year period stipulated in the buy-out agreement, LDS lost more than $ 11 million. Metromedia claims that, because there was a loss over the period, it owes the former LDS stockholders nothing. So it wants the $ 1.3 million it paid in 1983 and 1984 back, plus interest since then, the suit states. The 19 stockholders in LDS at the time of the purchase by Metromedia w ere Gary Scott, Lyn Noble Hawthorne, Mike Adkins, Terry Gould, Jack Guenther, Art Collier, Stanley Rosenberg, Louis Nelson, Thomas Bloomer, David Mechler, Michael Reimherr, Don Freiling, James Burch, Charles Barrett, Michael Douglass, Ronald Walby, Raul Tamez, Robert Mahler, and Darrell Kirkland, according to an exhibit to the Metromedia suit. Meanwhile, four former LDS shareholders are alleging in a counterclaim that Metromedia owes them more under the profit agreement. The former shareholders, Thomas Bloomer, James Burch, Charles Barrett and Stanley Rosenberg, claim that Metromedia fired Scott as LDS president in 1984 so that it could scuttle future LDS profits and relieve itself of the burden of paying a percentage of those profits to the former shareholders in LDS. In their counterclaim, the former LDS shareholders allege that Metromedia. drained profits from LDS by charging debts to the company that actually should have been charged to Metromedia. The claim asks that the accounting records of Metromedia from the time of the LDS purchase through the end of the five-year profit-sharing agreement be opened for inspection. Another provision of the buy-out stipulated that the former LDS shareholders would receive $ 5 million, less any profit shares paid them, if Metromedia sold the assets or capital stock in LDS in the first five years following the LDS purchase, according to court documents. Metromedia did resell LDS during that period, and the former stockholders of LDS are entitled to receive the portion of the $ 5 million not previously paid as a share of earnings, the counterclaim alleges. The immediate battle, however, is over which court the suits will be tried in. Walraven and Cox & Smith partner Larry Macon both want to consolidate the cases in local state district court, they said. PAGE 21 San Antonio Business Journal 1990 UMI/Data Courier Scott, Hughes and Rogers filed the first suit in the local state district court late in June. But Communications Services had the suit removed to the U.S. District Court for the Western District of Texas San Antonio Division late in July. Subsequent suits have been filed in the federal court or removed to federal court from state district courts around the state. The U.S. Western District court is overburdened with criminal cases, and long delays for civil procedures there can be expected, said Walraven. Macon, who is representing former LDS shareholders, said that Metromedia lawyers first filed their suits in the overburdened state district courts in Harris and Montgomery counties, and since has been attempting to keep them in the local federal court to delay their trial. Attorneys representing Metromedia and Communications Services declined any comment on the litigation. SUBJECT: Telecommunications industry; Long distance carriers; Litigation; Acquisitions & mergers; Southwest; Middle Atlantic NAME: Gary Scott; Robert Hughes; Johnnie Rogers GEOGRAPHIC: Southwest Region; San Antonio; TX; US COMPANY: Long Distance Services Inc; SIC: 4813 Metromedia Co; DUNS: 00-698-7630; SIC: 4813;4812;1721;7371 CO: METROMEDIA CO; LOAD-DATE-MDC: September 19, 1990 ---